I clearly remember the day when my dad enrolled me in college and left. Education in India and for that matter specifically in Tamil Nadu is very straightforward. You work hard to get good grades and take the entrance exam. Your selection to the top colleges is based on the rankings which is a combination of the two. If you are on top, there are no doubts about getting into the top ranking colleges. Very simple and efficient.
Whereas, the higher education in the US is very complex and the choices are limitless. For a senior, especially one with 3.96 GPA, 12 APs above 4, working a part-time job, participating in National honor society by volunteering hours at the community, doing a senior project in robotics, achieved brown belt in Karate, likes mainstream rappers as well as obscure ones and of course crazy about the NFL, NBA team stats of the players, the choices are even more complicated.
His dream was to become a Mechanical Engineer and complete the MBA program to become an entrepreneur. I am glad he was so specific about his objectives considering the fact that, I wanted to become a Civil Engineer but within few weeks I changed to Electrical and Electronics, now I work in IT.
He was admitted to University of California, Berkeley and Barrett Honors College in Arizona State University. Both very different colleges with very different offerings. A quick comparison will tell you that Berkeley far surpasses Arizona State University and there should not even be a decision involved here to pick the right choice. This is what meets everybody’s eyes but my son chose Barrett in ASU for the reasons below. I am writing this blog post for anyone who are debating on the choices.
The comparison cited above compares the bigger Arizona State University with 70,000 students with UC Berkeley and does not take into consideration the Barrett College within ASU. Barrett is the honors college with around 2000 freshman and was started to capture and retain the extraordinary student talent within Arizona. Berkeley does not have a comparable college and their take is that everybody here is an exceptional achiever. This is good and bad. Good because it is a level playing field for all the resources available and bad because the students have to work very very hard to the point of burning out to compete with each other.
With Barrett honors, the students are given priority student advisement and are provided with world class housing and dining options which are otherwise not available to the regular students. The Barrett program is isolated from the University and has its own boundaries. The housing is spectacular when compared to the old dilapidated structures in Berkeley (they really are and we were surprised). These Honors students are given opportunities to participate in Research during their undergraduate year wheres in Berkeley it would be next to impossible to get access to these opportunities. Another distinguishing factor was that the entire faculty in Barrett are dedicated to supporting the limited number of freshman when compared to the large number in Berkeley.
With regards to the machine shop, we were made aware in Berkeley that only Junior students are provided access and can tinker things. With Barrett the students will have the opportunities in Freshman when they can sign up for EPICS program that will make them tinker to solve a community problem.
Being the resident of the state and for his academic excellence he got a full tuition ride in Barrett with a Presidential scholarship. It may be a different situation if the college costs were comparable to Barrett when the decision would have been equalized. However, our situation was unique and will be different for different individuals.
Though part of me was siding with Berkeley, my son made the decision easier when he signed up for the orientation and enrolled himself in Barrett. According to him, he would like to complete the undergraduate in Barrett and pursue his graduate studies in out-of-state university although Barrett has a 4+1 program in which he can earn his graduation in 5 years. He said, “Dad I would rather be a big fish in small pond rather than a small fish in a big pond” and I was speechless.
Fast forward four years, he is out of ASU and came out with flying colors. We don’t doubt his decision and he is pursuing his dreams.